Solution-Based Feedback. As a writer, you may be extremely skilled or you may need a lot of hand-holding and guidance. In later drafts, you can focus more on these lower-order problems.If you feel that the manuscript you read has many problems, you will overwhelm the writer if you try to pick apart every single one of them. Lynda Dietz. Your goal is to write something that really speaks to people, informs people or otherwise engages readers.Less-than-perfect content is totally capable of this—sometimes it works even better. If you’re receiving constructive criticism via email or on paper, read everything the editor says. The primary difference is the level of analysis we bring to the work. But when you’re the person delivering the criticism, it can all go terribly wrong if you’re not careful. Getting away from it, even for a short period of time, is enough to reboot.If there are a lot of notes about a certain topic, and it’s one that was mentioned by more than one beta, for example, you may wish to pay closer attention to it. We encourage it, because it helps you to understand why we’ve made certain changes. I thought this was laying the groundwork to show that he is an uncaring husband, but that wasn’t the case. You may have preferences as a reader that are not related to the quality of a work. Even if the critic is doing it without any intentions to make the criticized person feel assaulted, there are strong chances of that individual to feel being invaded. How could you rewrite that section to better demonstrate his concern for his wife?”As much as you may be itching to tear apart that ridiculous section where Lucas doesn’t seem to care about his pregnant wife, you shouldn’t walk into a critique or deliver a written one that begins with all the things that are wrong with the story.

The point of someone asking for feedback is usually because they’re looking for some general guidance, not because they want you to totally decimate their writing. But if it’s done well, giving constructive criticism doesn’t have to be awkward or unpleasant for you or your co-worker. Instead, offer a few specific, high-quality pieces of criticism, and lay out succinct ways to fix them.Maybe you’re not the giver of feedback, you’re the recipient—and you aren’t particularly good at it. The underlying aim of constructive criticism is to point out the flaws in behavior and not personality. Define feedback. The first time I received a constructive critique of my writing in a professional setting, I left the meeting feeling defeated. Sending your work off to be edited can be a scary thing. B. We encourage new writers to publish with us, a rarity in the blogging world.New articles are published every Tuesday and we’ve got an increasing number of video content available too.Your donations help to fund hosting costs and the time it takes to create these resources. Editor Rachel Rowlands talks about this in an excellent article, “Sometimes, the simple act of categorizing things helps us to see a pattern much more clearly than trying to look at the big picture.Recognize why the editor made each change and always, always assume the reader will notice.Let’s face it, there are readers out there who will overlook bushels of typos because they’re in it for the Happily Ever After and they just don’t care. Make sure you feel good about the content you’ve created before you seek constructive criticism, or you could be setting yourself up for a particularly brutal feedback session.Now you understand how beneficial constructive criticism can be, it’s hard to deny feedback is an integral part of the writing and editing process. Please hand over your keyboard and stand in the corner.”Trust me, even when a manuscript is a train wreck, your editor will never say those words.
Written by. Think of Take feedback to heart and get better because of it.There’s no wrong time to ask for feedback. This fact is all the more reason that these two things are not your job as a critiquer:Realising these two points can actually free you up to deliver more helpful critiques. Positive, specific critiques should recognise where both the writer and the draft are in their development and should emphasise gentle suggestions for improvement over bludgeoning the writer with the things that they have done wrong. Keep in mind that you need to critique the work that is written, not the work you would have preferred had you written the story yourself.“On page 35, Lucas finds out his pregnant wife has been hospitalised, and he has no other information on her condition. Put a positive spin on It. Think of how many ideas we come up with while showering or driving, while walking through the woods, or when we’re just resting in a peaceful setting.